Original article Midterm outcomes of prospective, randomized, single-center study of the Janus tacrolimus-eluting stent for treatment of native coronary artery lesions
HAN Ya-ling, WANG Shou-li, JING Quan-min, YU Hai-bo, WANG Bin, MA Ying-yan, LUAN Bo and WANG Geng
Keywords: drug-eluting stent; acute myocardial infarction; angioplasty, transluminal; percutaneous coronary
Background Long-term efficacy and safety of tacrolimus-eluting stent (Janus) for treatment of coronary artery disease in percutaneous coronary interventions (PCI) “real world” is uncertain. The aim of this study was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of Janus stent for treating coronary heart disease in PCI daily practice, the safety of 4-month clopidogrel therapy after Janus stent implantation and the feasibility for treating patients with acute myocardial infarction (AMI) for first time. Methods From February 20, 2006 to August 26, 2006, a total of 200 patients were enrolled and randomly assigned to receive either Janus stent (n=100) or bare metal stent (Tecnic Carbostent, n=100). All patients were administered with clopidogrel for 4 months and aspirin for life long after stenting. Results Baseline clinical and angiographic characteristics were comparable between the two groups. AMI was present in 37% of patients with Janus and 36% with Tecnic Carbostent. At an average of 246-day follow-up, major adverse cardiac events (MACE) was 6% with the Janus stent and 15% with the Tecnic Carbostent (P=0.038). Primary events included 1 cardiac death, 1 myocardial infarction (MI) due to subacute stent thrombosis and 13 target lesion revascularizations (TLR) due to restenosis in patients with Tecnic Carbostent and 6 TLR due to restenosis in patients with Janus stent. Although all patients had discontinued clopidogrel for an average of 126 days, there was no additional thrombotic event in the two groups. Conclusions Janus stent is efficient in reducing MACE compared with Tecnic Carbostent at an average of 8-month follow-up. Discontinuation of clopidogrel at 4 months after PCI is safe for patients with Janus stent, including AMI patients. Long-term efficacy of Janus stent in reducing restenosis requires further study.
rug-eluting stent (DES) has been reported to
Ddramatically reduce the incidence of restenosis and
target lesion revascularization (TLR), and is widely used
Study population
in clinical practice in recent years. However, Between February 20, 2006 and August 26, 2006, a total
controversies remain with regard to the long-term
of 200 patients with symptomatic or documented
efficacy and safety for the first generation DES.1
myocardial ischemia, including acute myocardial
Pathological findings had indicated that polymer based DES delayed vessel healing, which might lead to late
infarction (AMI), were enrolled in this prospective,
severe adverse events such as in-stent thrombosis. The
randomized study. Patients were considered eligible for
permanent existence of non-degradable polymer coatings,
enrollment if they were: fit for coronary stent
which promote local vessel inflammation, is considered
implantation; to be treated exclusively with one kind of
as one of the leading causes reducing vessel healing. The
stent, no more than 3 stents for one target vessel (or total
Janus tacrolimus-eluting stent (SORIN, Italy), a novel
length of stents ≤ 85 mm), and providing written
DES without polymer coating, is deemed capable to
informed consent. The major exclusion criteria were
eliminate the adverse effects of non-degradable polymer
in-stent restenosis lesion, graft lesion, not eligible for
coatings of DES. Preliminary clinical outcomes from
DES implantation, such as intolerant of anti-platelet
Jupiter I and II studies demonstrated that Janus stent was
treatment or planned to undergo surgery, and
as safe as bare metal stent (BMS) and tended to reduce
restenosis rate. However, the study population in Jupiter I
and II comprised of only low to mid-risk patients and
Department of Cardiology, Shenyang General Hospital of PLA,
lesions. We conducted a prospective, randomized,
Shenyang 110016, China (Han YL, Wang SL, Jing QM, Yu HB,
single-center study aiming at evaluating the safety and
efficacy of Janus stent for treating coronary artery disease
Correspondence to: Dr. Han Ya-ling, Department of Cardiology,
in “real world” clinical practice of percutaneous coronary
Shenyang General Hospital of PLA, Shenyang 110016, China
Chinese Medical Journal 2007;120 (7):552-556Study protocols Table 1. Baseline clinical characteristics
Patients were randomly assigned to receive Janus stent
(n=100, Janus group) or Tecnic Carbostent (SORIN, Italy,
n=100. Tecnic group) according to the computer
generated randomization list. A 300-600 mg loading dose
clopidogrel (Plavix, Sanofi aventis) were given for all
patients at admission. Coronary angiography and stenting
were performed according to the standard techniques.2
After stent implantation, all patients received dual
antiplatelet therapy: aspirin 300 mg per day for the initial
one month continued with 100 mg per day for life-long
and clopidogrel 75 mg per day for 4 months. In patients
with AMI, the antiplatelet regimen was mostly the same
except clopidogrel 150 mg per day for the initial one
week. Clinical follow-up was performed at 1-, 6-, 12- and
CAD: coronary artery disease. AMI: acute myocardial infarction. LMWH: low
24-month and follow-up angiography was performed at 9
molecular weight heparin. PCI: percutaneous coronary intervention. NYHA:
New York Heart Association. NS: not significant.
End points and definitions
characteristics of the two groups were well matched
The primary end point was the 12-month rate of major
(Table 2). Multivessel disease was present in 7% of
adverse cardiac events (MACE), defined as the composite
patients in Janus group and 13% of patients in Tecnic
of cardiac death, nonfatal myocardial infarction (MI) or
group (All were dual vessel disease, P>0.05).
TLR. The secondary end points were 9-month rate of angiographic in-stent restenosis and MACE at 24-month.
MI was defined either as the development of pathological
Table 2. Baseline angiographic characteristics
Q waves in at least 2 contiguous leads with or without
elevated cardiac enzymes or, in the absence of
pathological Q waves, as an elevation in creatinine kinase
levels to greater than twice the upper limit of normal in
the presence of an elevated creatinine kinase-MB level.
Location of target lesions (n (%))
TLR was defined as repeat revascularization for ischemia
owing to stenosis ≥ 50% of the lumen diameter
anywhere within the stent or within the 5-mm borders
proximal or distal to the stent. Restenosis was defined as
the diameter stenosis of ≥50% of the target lesion.
Statistical analysis
Categorical discrete variables were compared by the χ2
test or the Fisher exact test when appropriate. Continuous
variables were presented as mean±standard deviation
Small vessel lesions (≤2.75 mm) (n (%)) 12(10.6) 14(11.5) NS
(SD) and were compared with the use of the Student’s t
Long lesions (≥20 mm) (n (%)) 81(71.7)
test. A P value <0.05 was considered statistically
99%−100% diameter stenosis (n (%)) 48(42.5) 48(39.3) NS
significant. Data were analyzed using SPSS 10.0.
LM: left main. LAD: left anterior descending coronary artery. LCX: left
circumflex coronary artery. RCA: right coronary artery. CTO: chronic total occlusion. ACC/AHA: American College of Cardiology/American Heart
Baseline clinical characteristics The baseline clinical characteristics of the two groups Procedural results
were well matched (Table 1). Onset of AMI within 24
There were totally 235 target lesions in 220 target vessel
hours occurred in 37 patients in Janus group (including 4
of 200 observed patients underwent coronary stenting.
non-ST segment elevation MI) and in 36 in Tecnic group
The procedure and device-deployment success rates
(including 3 non-ST segment elevation MI). The
achieved 100% in the two groups. Procedural results were
proportions of acute coronary syndromes (ACS) were
similar for the two groups (Table 3). The maximum total
78% in Janus group and 75% in Tecnic group,
stent length in one vessel was 81 mm in patients
implanted with the Janus stent and 71 mm in patients
implanted with Tecnic carbostent (overlapped by 3 stents).
Baseline angiographic characteristics
Stents with small diameter (2.5-2.75 mm) accounted for
The target lesions (113 vs 122) and target vessels (107 12.3% in Janus group and 17.0% in Tecnic group vs 113) were similar between the two groups. Lesion
Table 3. Stent implantation and procedural results
of inspiritment. Because of the growing concern that
delayed endothelialization after implantation of a DES
may cause late stent thrombosis, prolonged dual
antiplatelet therapy with clopidogrel and aspirin is
currently recommended after DES implantation.
Unfortunately, even with 6 months or longer period of
dual antiplatelet therapy, the incidence of late thrombosis
2.5 mm diameter stent (n (%)) 11(9.0)
or deadly cardiac events after DES implantation were still
2.75 mm diameter stent (n (%)) 4(3.3)
higher than those after BMS implantation.3 Therefore, it
3.0 mm - 4.0 mm diameter stent (n (%)) 107(87.7) 112(83.0) NS Stent overlapping (
is important to develop a new generation of DES which
might decrease the restenosis not at the expense of safety.
The Janus tacrolimus-eluting stent is one of such new
Distal protective device (n (%)) 0(0) 1(1) NS
generation DES. As the platform of Janus stent, the
Tecnic Carbostent is coated with Carbofilm to increase
the biocompatibility and hemocompatibility.4,5 Phantom
IV study demonstrated the efficacy and safety of Tecnic
Overall clinical outcomes
Carbostent. In that study, there was no death or MI at
Up to January 30, 2007, all patients were clinically
6-month clinical follow-up after Tecnic Carbostent
followed up for an average of (246±48) days (ranged
implantation, and the angiographic restenosis rate was
150 to 340 days). All the patients discontinued
14%.6 Of the 100 patients received the Tecnic Carbostent
clopidogrel at the end of the fourth month after PCI
in the present study, the stent related thrombotic events
according to study protocol. The mean interval from the
rate was only 1% at an average of 8-month follow-up,
discontinuation of clopidogrel was (126 ± 46) days
which confirms that the Tecnic Carbostent is a safe BMS
(ranged 34 to 220 days). Primary events occurred in 15
platform. Having kept the structural features of the Tecnic
patients in Tecnic group, including 1 cardiac death due to
Carbostent, the Janus stent is coated with tacrolimus, an
cardiac rupture secondary to anterior AMI, 1 AMI caused
immunosuppressant, which was demonstrated to be
by subacute in-stent thrombosis, 12 repeat PCI and 1
efficient in inhibiting neointima hyperplasia of porcine
CABG due to in-stent restenosis, so the overall and
coronary artery.7,8 Differed from the first generation DES,
stent-related MACE rates were 15% and 14%, i.e. Cypher and TAXUS, Janus stent has some unique
respectively. In Janus group, there were 6 primary events
features. First, drugs are loaded in the embedded
of repeat PCI due to in-stent restenosis, so the overall and
reservoirs on the outer stent surface, which enables drugs
stent-related MACE rates were all 6%. The overall
releasing directly to vessel wall without being washed
MACE rate was significantly lower in Janus group as
away in the bloodstream. Second, there is no polymer
compared with Tecnic group (6% vs 15%, P=0.038). For
coating in Janus stent, which may decrease the potential
the TLR and stent-related MACE, there was an obvious
risks of late in-stent thrombosis caused by unabsorbable
tendency of lower incidence associated with the Janus
stent but not statistically significant (6% vs 14%,
Jupiter I study, the first-in-man registry of Janus stent, enrolled 58 patients. Of whom, 19% were ACS (including
Clinical outcomes of AMI subgroup For the subgroup of AMI patients who underwent
6.9% of AMI). The target lesions included only 27%
emergent PCI within 24 hours of symptom onset, the
complex lesions of type B2/C with (11.5±5.9) mm of
mean clinical follow-up was (250±46) days (ranged 154
lesion length and (70.3±14.9)% of stenosis diameter.
to 323 days) in Janus group and (243±52) days (ranged
The randomized, controlled Jupiter II study presented at
150 to 340 days) in Tecnic group, respectively. There was
2005 TCT showed that the total rate of MACE in the 157
no death or any thrombotic event in 37 patients in Janus
patients of Janus group was 7.6%, in which 6.4% of
group except 3 repeat PCI due to in-stent restenosis. In 36
MACE was related to the stent, suggesting Janus stent
patients in Tecnic group, there were 4 primary end points,
having better clinical effects and safety. However, ACS
including 1 cardiac death, 1 MI caused by subacute
accounted for only 27.6% of patients in Janus group in
in-stent thrombosis and 2 repeat PCI due to in-stent
Jupiter II. Furthermore, ST segment elevation MI
restenosis. The incidence of death or MI was similar
(STEMI) within 7 days and non-ST segment elevation MI
(NSTEMI) within 3 days were all excluded in Jupiter II.
patients had discontinued clopidogrel, there was no
It also excluded those with complicated lesions such as
additional death or thrombotic event in the two groups.
ostial lesions, left main diseases, chronic total occlusions
(CTO), bifurcations, lesion in small vessels (reference
DISCUSSION
diameter ≤ 2.75 mm), long lesions (lesion length >20
mm) and thrombotic lesions. Complex lesions of Type
Controversies about DES regarding its late clinical
B2/C took only 34.9%. Because of the relatively simple
outcomes were emerged and spread after the initial years
lesion type, 75.9% of patients underwent successful direct
Chinese Medical Journal 2007;120 (7):552-556
stenting. Compared with Jupiter I and II studies, the
always confused to decide how long patients should take
population in the present study included 78% of ACS
dual antiplatelet therapy after DES implantation. In
patients. The target lesions included many complicated
Jupiter II study, about 60% patients took clopidogrel for
lesions of high risk, such as left main or ostial lesions,
over 6 months. Although patients in present study took
thrombotic lesions, CTO, bifurcations, long lesions, small
clopidogrel for 4 months and then aspirin alone, no
vessel lesions with 2.5 mm in diameter. Some of the
thrombosis was found after discontinuation of clopidogrel
patients were highly endangered by some risk factors of
for 126 days on average, preliminarily proving the
coronary heart disease, for instance, diabetes, smoking
feasibility and safety of this antiplatelet regimen, which
and hypertension, which generally reflected the “real
provides an opportunity of receiving DES for patients
world” of clinical PCI daily practice. Despite of the
who are intolerable of long-term dual antiplatelet therapy.
higher risk for clinic and restenosis in subjects of present
The relatively shorter dual antiplatelet regimen may also
study, the incidence of MACE was 6% without
associate with a decrease of the hemorrhage risk, adverse
occurrence of death or thrombosis in Janus group during
the mean 8-month follow-up. Besides, as compared with
the Tecnic group, incidence of MACE was dramatically
The main limitation of our study lies in that the mean
follow-up period is only 8 months, which does not reach
P=0.038). The rate of stent related MACE had
an obvious lower tendency in Janus group but no
the designed observation time and only reflects the
mid-term clinical result. Because of the limited
similar to that of Jupiter I and II, and further confirms the
observation time, angiographic follow-up rate is low as
safety and clinical efficacy of Janus stent. Different from
the present study, Jupiter II did not achieve statistical
differences in the total rate of MACE, which might
In conclusion, for the first time we investigated the
mainly due to the differences in study population. The
efficacy and safety of the Janus stent, a novel DES
enrolled patients in Jupiter II were mostly at lower risk
without polymer coating, in “real world” PCI practice in
for thrombosis. It has been reported that the effect of DES
this randomized single-center study. At our mean 8-month
in reducing restenosis is not superior to that of BMS for
follow-up, Janus stent is efficient in reducing MACE
lesions with length <15 mm and vessel diameter >2.8
compared with BMS, and is safe and efficient for treating
mm.10 Moreover, Tecnic stent itself has certain AMI patients. Discontinuation of clopidogrel at 4-month antithrombotic function which may reduce the thrombosis
related events in the control group in Jupiter II, in which
late lumen lost was only 0.64 mm, and the incidence of
in-stent restenosis was 14.8% in patients implanted with
Tecnic stent. This was probably the reason for Jupiter II
1. Moses JW, Leon MB, Popma JJ, Fitzgerald PJ, Holmes DR,
to come to the conclusion that the total incidences of
O’Shaughnessy C, et al. Sirolimus-eluting stents versus
MACE and stent related MACE in Janus group were not
standard stents in patients with stenosis in a native coronary
significantly lower than those in Tecnic group.
artery. N Engl J Med 2003; 349: 1315-1323.
2. Han YL, Wang G, Jing QM, Wang SL, Wang ZL, Wang DM,
Up to now, the safety of DES implantation in primary
et al. Percutaneous coronary intervention in acute coronary
PCI is uncertain. The randomized Typhoon trial showed
syndrome: single center experience from 4670 patients. Natl
that sirolimus eluting stent for treatment of STEMI was
efficient in reducing MACE and TLR compared with
3. Pfisterer M, Brunner-La Rocca HP, Buser PT, Rickenbacher P,
BMS, but not beneficial for death, MI or in-stent
Hunziker P, Mueller C, et al. Late clinical events after
thrombosis.11 In the present study, more than a third of
clopidogrel discontinuation may limit the benefit of
study population were those with STEMI or NSTEMI
drug-eluting stents. J Am Coll Cardiol 2006; 48: 2584-2591.
undergoing emergent PCI within 24 hours of symptom
4. Morice MC, Serruys PW, Sousa JE, Fajadet J, Ban Hayashi E,
onset, which were excluded in Jupiter I and II study. For
Perin M, et al. A randomized comparison of a
37 AMI patients (including 33 STEMI) in Janus group, no
sirolimus-eluting stent with standard stent for coronary
acute, subacute or late thrombosis occurred at an average
revascularization. N Engl J Med 2002; 346: 1773-1780.
8-month follow-up, suggesting Janus stent is safe in
5. Sousa JE, Costa MA, Abizaid AC, Rensing BJ, Abizaid AS,
Tanajura LF, et al. Sustained suppression of neointimal
proliferation by sirolimus-eluting stents: one-year
It was reported that incomplete endothelialization even
angiographic and intravascular ultrasound follow-up.
appeared 1-2 years after implantation of Cypher or
TAXUS in some cases.12 The reports of very late in-stent
6. Danzi GB, Capuano C, Sesana M, Baglini R, Bartorelli AL,
thrombosis (>1 year) after DES implantation were also
Trabattoni D, et al. Six-month clinical and angiographic
not rare.13 Long-term dual antiplatelet therapy may
outcomes of the tecnic carbostentTM coronary system: the
reduce the risk of thrombosis, but simultaneously
phantom IV study. J In vasasive Cardiol 2004; 11: 641-644.
accompanies the increased adverse effects, such as
7. Kollum M, Farb A, Schreiber R, Terfera K, Arab A, Geist A, et
hemorrhage, and the financial burden. Therefore, it is
al. Particle debris from a nanoporous stent coating obscures
potential antiproliferative effects of tacrolimus-eluting stents
in a porcine model of restenosis. Catheter Cardiovasc Interv
11. Spaulding C, Henry P, Teiger E, Beatt K, Bramucci E, Carre D,
et al. Sirolimus-eluting versus uncoated stents in acute
8. Scheller B, Grandt A, Wnendt S, Lorenz G, Bohm M,
myocardial infarction. N Engl J Med 2006; 355: 1093-1104.
Nickenig G. Comparative study of tacrolimus and paclitaxel
12. Kotani J, Awata M, Nanto S, Uematsu M, Oshima F,
stent coating in the porcine coronary model. Z Kardiol 2005;
Minamiquchi H, et al. Incomplete neointimal coverage of
sirolimus-eluting stents: angioscopic findings. J Am Coll
Trabattoni D, Fabbiocchi F, Montorsi P, Martini
SD, Calligaris G, et al. Synergy of passive coating and targeted
13. Takahashi S, Kaneda H, Tanaka S, Miyashita Y, Shiono T,
drug delivery: the tacrolimus-eluting Janus Carbostent. J
Taketani Y, et al. Late angiographic stent thrombosis after
sirolimus-eluting stent implantation. Circ J 2007; 71: 226-228.
10. Pache J, Dibra A, Mehili J, Dirschinger J, Schomig A, Kastrati
A. Drug-eluting stents compared with thin-strut bare stents for
the reduction of restenosis: a prospective, randomized trial.
Edited by WANG Mou-yue and SHEN Xi-bin
5. Phillips EJ, Keystone JS, Kain KC. Failure by early 2006, only sporadic cases obtained from the health and market of combined chloroquine and high-dose were found. In July 2006, an outbreak authorities. Oral consent for interview primaquine therapy for Plasmodium vivax malaria acquired in Guyana, South Amer-of HPAI was confi rmed on 2 chicken was obtained from participants. ica. Clin In
RASHAUN P. SOURLES 4750 E. 53rd St., Unit 103 Minneapolis, MN 55417 Tweet @rashaunps STRATEGIC BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT & MARKETING MANAGER Comprehensive experience in sales, marketing and new business development—including personal client relations, project leadership and total account management. Skilled in strategic planning and high-impact, target marketing; deter